Finished: Mutiny on the Bounty Trilogy, by Charles Nordoff and James Norman Hall 📚. My copy of these 1930’s novels is a more recent reprint bound as a single (700-page) volume, though you can also buy the novels separately.

Mutiny on the Bounty itself is the strongest of the three, which is probably why it’s the only one most people know. It tells of the voyage of the Bounty, the mutiny, and the fate of a few of the sailors who were arrested on Tahiti after Captain Bligh returned to England. It has the court-martial records as a major source, and so is pretty well fleshed out (though the authors clearly filled in gaps and romanticized some things).

Men Against the Sea tells of the long voyage the Bligh and some of the non-mutinous sailors took in a tiny boat to Java, whence they eventually made it back to England. This 3600-mile voyage is right up with Shackleton’s better-known one in terms of adventure, but the major source is Bligh’s own sketchy log and so there were a lot of blanks to fill in.

Pitcairn’s Island is the story of the remaining mutineers, their isolated settlement, their downfall into violence and murder, and their eventual rediscovery. All we really have for source material here are the conflicting and likely self-serving recollections of the last surviving mutineer, so the authors have had to pretty much fantasize about what actually happened.

If you like sea yarns, though, the whole trilogy is worth reading; I never once thought of putting the book down unfinished.